Compressors Comparison Test, issue 6.6, November 2003. WinWord file Fileware.doc (427,520 bytes)

Compressors Comparison Test, issue 6.6, November 2003.

WinWord file Fileware.doc (427,520 bytes)

Environment:

iPIII-840, 256Mb SDRAM, XPsp1,
IBM Deskstar 80Gb.

@ Fileware.doc (WinWord file) (427,520 bytes)

Remark	Archiver and used options	Algorithm	Packed size	Packed ratio	Packing time (sec.)	Unpacking time (sec.)	Rating (sec.)
*	7zip 3.11 7z LZMA	LZMA	107040	0.750	0.76	0.15	30.64
*	durilca/lt 0.3 t1(7,(2-2))	f+PPMII	105828	0.752	1.55	0.52	31.47
	durilca/lt 0.3 t1	f+PPMII	107476	0.749	1.39	0.41	31.65
*	rar 3.20b4 m5	LZH/PPMII	113132	0.735	0.42	0.17	32.02
	rar 3.20b4 m4	LZH/PPMII	113504	0.735	0.39	0.18	32.10
*	uharc 0.5' mx	f+PPM	102278	0.761	2.18	1.56	32.15
*	rar 3.20b4 m5 mct+	PPMII	112600	0.737	0.57	0.42	32.27
	uharc 0.5' m3	f+LZ+Ari	109817	0.743	1.60	0.41	32.51
	uharc 0.5' mm-	f+LZ+Ari	112777	0.736	0.84	0.34	32.51
	jar32 1.02d m4	LZ+Huf	114238	0.733	0.70	0.14	32.57
	jar32 1.02d m3	LZ+Huf	114237	0.733	0.69	0.15	32.57
*	arjz 0.50 mp9 md2m	LZ+Huf	116843	0.727	0.42	0.07	32.95
	arjz 0.50 mp8	LZ+Huf	117275	0.726	0.34	0.08	33.00
*	arjz 0.50 md2m	LZ+Huf	117451	0.725	0.31	0.07	33.01
	rolz' 1.02	ROLZ	112022	0.738	1.72	0.18	33.02
	arjz 0.50	LZ+Huf	117780	0.725	0.31	0.07	33.10
*	ppmonstr Ir1 o16 m64	PPMII	100559	0.765	2.49	2.72	33.14
	ppmd I o16 m64	PPMII	116326	0.728	0.41	0.46	33.18
	rar 3.20b4 m5 mct-	LZ+Huf	118572	0.723	0.34	0.07	33.35
	rkc 1.02 T1024 mf	ROLZ	110968	0.740	2.31	0.23	33.36
	ppmn 1.00b1++ O9	PPM	112175	0.738	1.09	1.15	33.40
*	imp 1.10 -1 m3 u1000	LZ+Huf	119213	0.721	0.23	0.07	33.41
	ppmn 1.00b1++	PPM	113940	0.733	0.86	0.95	33.46
	ctx 0.75b1 me ftemsl	PPMII	116659	0.727	0.52	0.54	33.47
	durilca/lt 0.3	PPMII	117620	0.725	0.40	0.43	33.50
	imp 1.10 -1 u1000	LZ+Huf	119763	0.720	0.23	0.07	33.57
*	durilca 0.3	PPMII	99584	0.767	2.98	2.98	33.62
	ppmonstr Ir1	PPMII	103909	0.757	2.32	2.53	33.71
	cabarc 1.00 LZX:21	LZ+Huf	118011	0.724	0.88	0.06	33.72
	rkc 1.02 -mf	ROLZ	111854	0.738	2.42	0.23	33.72
	cabarc 1.00 LZX:18	LZ+Huf	118473	0.723	0.90	0.04	33.85
*	durilca 0.3 t1(7,(2-2))	f+PPMII	94416	0.779	4.36	3.27	33.86
	lzds 2.1 s1024 m5	LZ+Ari	120688	0.718	0.31	0.07	33.90
	lzds 2.1 s1024 m4	LZ+Ari	120799	0.717	0.29	0.07	33.92
*	ppmonstr Ir1 o128 m64	PPMII	99574	0.767	3.04	3.23	33.93
	ctx 0.75b1 ftemsl	PPMII	118766	0.722	0.48	0.47	33.94
	lzds 2.1 s1024 m3	LZ+Ari	120953	0.717	0.29	0.07	33.96
	cabarc 1.00 LZX:15	LZ+Huf	119969	0.719	0.61	0.05	33.98
	ctx 0.75b1 me	f+PPMII	117660	0.725	0.80	0.54	34.02
	dst 0.9 mb	LZ+DHuf	119364	0.721	0.53	0.40	34.09
	arhangel 1.40a1 -1	LZ+Ari	121397	0.716	0.26	0.11	34.09
*	durilca 0.3 t1	f+PPMII	96690	0.774	4.10	3.14	34.10
	7zip 3.11 7z PPMD	PPMII	119694	0.720	0.47	0.50	34.22
	ace32 2.0c3 m4	LZ+Huf	119106	0.721	0.54	0.62	34.25
	dst 0.9 mb 4	LZ+DHuf	117767	0.725	1.11	0.43	34.25
	ctx 0.75b1	f+PPMII	119377	0.721	0.74	0.49	34.39
	ha 0.999c a1	LZ+Ari	121441	0.716	0.57	0.18	34.48
	uc 2.3.05 tt	LZ+Huf	123372	0.711	0.26	0.06	34.59
	7zip 3.11 zip	LZ+Huf	122465	0.714	0.47	0.11	34.60
	compressia 1.00	f+BWT+Ari	120737	0.718	0.69	0.42	34.65
	bee 0.77 m2d5	CM	106518	0.751	2.49	2.58	34.66
	dst 0.9 mg 4	LZ+(DHuf/PPM)	117666	0.725	1.39	0.67	34.75
	uc 2.3.05 tn	LZ+Huf	124200	0.709	0.23	0.04	34.77
	ppmd I	PPMII	123315	0.712	0.30	0.36	34.91
	compressia 1.00 e	f+BWT+Ari	120737	0.718	0.84	0.57	34.95
	7zip 3.11 zip mx	LZ+Huf	121563	0.716	1.07	0.12	34.96
	dzip 2.90 -9	LZ+Huf	125391	0.707	0.24	0.05	35.12
	GRZipII 0.2.1 -a	BWT+Ari	123968	0.710	0.40	0.29	35.13
*	esp 1.92	LZ+Huf	126095	0.705	0.13	0.03	35.19
*	dzip 2.90	LZ+Huf	125984	0.705	0.13	0.07	35.20
	bee 0.77 m3d5	CM	106039	0.752	2.87	3.04	35.37
	GRZipII 0.2.1 m2 -a	BWT+Ari	125596	0.706	0.33	0.19	35.41
	lz (Kabanov) 5	LZ+Huf	126164	0.705	0.29	0.11	35.45
	lz (Kabanov) 6	LZ+Huf	126146	0.705	0.31	0.12	35.47
	sbc 0.969	f+BWT+Ari	124787	0.708	0.52	0.30	35.48
	lz (Kabanov) 4	LZ+Huf	126260	0.705	0.29	0.13	35.49
	pkzip 2.50 max	LZ+Huf	127735	0.701	0.15	0.06	35.69
	pkzip 2.50	LZ+Huf	128161	0.700	0.12	0.07	35.79
	GRZipII 0.2.1	BWT+Ari	126735	0.704	0.40	0.30	35.90
	GRZipII 0.2.1 m2	BWT+Ari	128603	0.699	0.34	0.20	36.26
	GRZipII 0.2.1 -p	BWT+Ari	128135	0.700	0.45	0.29	36.33
	arc' (I.Sutton) b2	BWT+Ari	128685	0.699	0.35	0.24	36.34
	sbc 0.969 b3m1	f+BWT+Ari	128686	0.699	0.42	0.24	36.41
	uharc 0.5' mz	f+LZP	128525	0.699	0.37	0.43	36.50
	arc' (I.Sutton)	BWT+Ari	129479	0.697	0.34	0.23	36.54
	ybs 0.03f -m256k	BWT+Ari	130136	0.696	0.35	0.18	36.68
	GRZipII 0.2.1 m3	BWT+Ari	130123	0.696	0.32	0.35	36.82
	uhbc 1.0 m1	BWT+Ari	129153	0.698	0.56	0.41	36.85
	boa 0.58b m7	PPM	118635	0.723	1.96	1.95	36.86
	rkc 1.02 -mx	PPM	103333	0.758	3.96	4.28	36.94
	epm r9	f+PPMII	95543	0.777	5.23	5.18	36.95
	GRZipII 0.2.1 m4	BWT+Ari	131490	0.692	0.25	0.24	37.02
	uhbc 1.0	BWT+Ari	128270	0.700	0.80	0.63	37.06
	uhbc 1.0 m0	BWT+Ari	130834	0.694	0.45	0.31	37.10
	bwtcoder2/ybs	BWT+Ari	130472	0.695	0.52	0.36	37.12
	bwtcoder2/dc	BWT+Ari	130490	0.695	0.48	0.43	37.16
	gca 0.90k	BWT+Ari	131559	0.692	0.46	0.23	37.23
	boa 0.58b m15	PPM	118928	0.722	2.23	2.17	37.44
	uhbc 1.0 m3	BWT+Ari	128167	0.700	1.07	0.90	37.57
	ba 1.01b5 -24-r	BWT+Ari	132651	0.690	0.42	0.30	37.57
	dc 0.99.298 -a	BWT+Ari	133825	0.687	0.36	0.18	37.71
	ybs 0.03f	BWT+Ari	133855	0.687	0.36	0.23	37.77
	bwc/PGCC 0.99 m900k	BWT+Ari	134183	0.686	0.32	0.19	37.78
	abc 2.4 -1	BWT+Ari	133494	0.688	0.43	0.31	37.82
	qlfc 6.6w	BWT+Ari	133734	0.687	0.48	0.23	37.86
	zzip 0.35g -a1	BWT+Ari	132711	0.690	0.67	0.36	37.89
	ba 1.01b5	BWT+Ari	133904	0.687	0.41	0.30	37.91
	imp 1.10 -2 u1000	BWT+Huf	135367	0.683	0.30	0.12	38.02
	bzip2/PGCC 1.0b7 -9	BWT+Huf	134932	0.684	0.43	0.14	38.05
	zzip 0.35g -mx	BWT+Ari	133803	0.687	0.68	0.36	38.21
	eri 5.10fre m1	ST+PPM	132115	0.691	1.08	0.46	38.24
	arc' (I.Sutton) m1	BWT+Ari	136742	0.680	0.17	0.18	38.33
	exp1 1.	BWT+Huf	135002	0.684	0.76	0.12	38.38
	szip 1.12 b21 o0	BWT+Ari	134945	0.684	0.90	0.18	38.56
	ICT UC 1.0	ST+Ari	136842	0.680	0.43	0.29	38.73
	szip 1.12 b21 o12	ST+Ari	136566	0.681	0.54	0.29	38.77
	arhangel 1.40a1 -2-mc8192	PPM	131613	0.692	1.23	1.07	38.86
	abc 2.4	BWT+Ari	135060	0.684	0.77	0.73	39.02
	szip 1.12 b21 o4	ST+Ari	141784	0.668	0.18	0.18	39.74
	xprs F	BWT+Ari	143597	0.664	0.37	0.13	40.39
	hap 3.00	PPM	140613	0.671	0.90	1.01	40.97
	eri 5.10fre	ST+PPM	144812	0.661	0.85	0.38	41.46
	ha 0.999c a2	PPM	134461	0.685	2.44	2.30	42.09
	bsic	BWT+Ari	141902	0.668	1.40	1.35	42.17
	ann p12	PPM+NN	137909	0.677	3.00	3.02	44.33
	rkc 1.02	PPMZ	98099	0.771	9.35	9.24	45.84
	paq3c	CM	112048	0.738	8.32	8.37	47.81
	paq3n/ic8	CM	104025	0.757	9.89	9.98	48.77
	ctw/es 0.1 n16M	CTW	125509	0.706	8.03	8.17	51.06
	ctw 0.1 n16M	CTW	125509	0.706	8.78	8.96	52.60
	ctw/es 0.1 n16M d8	CTW	124466	0.709	9.12	9.29	52.98
+	ppmy 2.02 9a9 m256 o64	CM	124930	0.708	9.38	9.86	53.94
	compressia 1.00 m	f+PPMII	101343	0.763	13.05	12.99	54.19
	compressia 1.00 em	f+PPMII	101343	0.763	13.27	13.22	54.64
	ctw/es 0.1 n16M d10	CTW	124066	0.710	9.95	10.30	54.71
	ctw 0.1 n16M d8	CTW	124466	0.709	10.10	10.04	54.71
	ash02	CM	108243	0.747	12.25	12.70	55.02
	ppmy 3c sse m256 o64	CM	125866	0.706	9.88	10.20	55.04
	enc 0.15 o6 m64	PPMII	107539	0.748	9.68	15.54	55.09
	enc 0.15 b o6m64	PPMII	105690	0.753	10.02	15.78	55.16
	enc 0.15 m64	PPMII	106765	0.750	10.01	15.95	55.62
*	slim 18	f+PPM*	94270	0.779	14.53	15.25	55.97
	ctw 0.1 n16M d10	CTW	124066	0.710	11.14	11.39	56.99
+	ppmy 2.02 9a9	CM	124848	0.708	12.68	13.13	60.49
	paq4	CM	99033	0.768	16.93	16.93	61.37
	ppmy 3c sse m256	CM	125780	0.706	13.12	13.36	61.42
	enc 0.15 b m64	PPMII	103633	0.758	13.60	19.66	62.05

Best compressor is near right bottom corner. Drag mouse to change time balance on Y axis

Marks:
* there are no another compressor, that compress better with faster compression and decompression speed.
' non public compressor.
Rating is calculated as a time required to compress file, transmit
it using 28000 bps connection and decompess file back.
Most of compressors are available at
ftp://ftp.elf.stuba.sk/pub/pc/pack
Vadim Yoockin ( yoockinv@mtu-net.ru ).