The Art of lossless image compression, 3rd release
Here are the results of 8 (eight) tests performed
to compare lossless compression of True Color (24-bit) images
by some general purpose archivers:
ERI32 3.0c4, UFA32 0.03b4, RKIVE 1.90b1, ESP 1.92, RAR 2.02, PKZIP 2.04g
(sorry, BOA, UHARC, HAP, SZIP and all
other archivers were not tested)
and results on same images of the famous PNG algorithm and format
created by Display 1.89a, CompuShow 2000! 2.04a, Image Alchemy 1.10.
If anybody wants to start or continue such tests,
or knows we have missed something important,
some new fantastic technology, an algorithm or even a program capable
of lossless compression of up to 1000:1 and lossy compression of
up to 10000:1 (we hear about it from time to time since our xts),
please let us know immediately: ratush@srsc-gw.sscc.ru Thanks!
[[1]] Ratio results only
(without details: please read also
[[2]] Time results
[[3]] Details
[[4]] How to download archivers
[[5]] PLEASE read THIS before replying to this article)
{ ERI32 } UFA32 RKIVE ESP RAR
23kodax 102.29% 100.05% 100% 100.32% 104.78% 109.70% 103.93% 107.49% 110.88%
16seqnc 101.03 105.47 100% 100.10 108.09 147.68 117.41 112.81 123.04
20canon 102.40 100% 100.26 100.36 102.20 129.46 118.22 104.34 100.50
21jpeg 101.72 101.51 101.70 100% 105.14 130.54 120.51 108.31 110.27
7 bzone 101.68 100.06 101.97 100% 112.90 143.70 140.22 117.16 119.98
28intel 103.99 100% 103.42 100.09 107.28 117.54 112.15 110.04 107.87
11misc 101.63 100% 101.46 100.06 108.20 123.46 118.65 111.37 111.55
14procs 100.76 100% 101.42 100.21 108.28 114.66 114.99 112.86 114.43
original { Display } CompuShow Alchemy Pkzip
230.43 128.84 132.49 131.88 130.32 128.51 128.93 132.43 141.41
253.03 134.41 162.96 155.10 148.45 144.28 142.09 135.77 150.31 184.26
198.27 117.73 122.22 113.99 114.46 112.82 109.73 115.54 158.53
198.81 118.86 123.51 121.98 121.19 119.97 116.75 122.60 154.55
222.40 136.41 134.94 131.02 130.98 129.94 127.67 132.69 171.46
197.56 122.02 120.02 114.16 118.64 114.51 112.34 112.27 119.97 150.79
206.69 118.75 116.93 113.50 112.82 111.75 108.64 108.78 114.41 153.58
232.01 120.42 119.93 114.76 115.52 114.15 112.65 112.43 117.76 149.61
[[2]] Time results
A SET of 23 images totalling 27,133,146 bytes
from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/still/KodakImages/color/
was used for this test, and a 486DX4-100 PC with 24Mb RAM running windows 95.
Programs,options Total length Compress_time Extract_time
bytes % min:sec % min:sec %
Eri32 3.0c4 -3ci 11747029 100% 15:54 100% 2:28 100%
-m3-3ci 11754269 100.06% 6:59 43.92% 2:24 97.29%
-m2-3ci 11902868 101.32% 4:08 25.99% 1:53 76.35%
-m1-3ci 12195535 103.81% 3:13 20.23% 1:42 68.91%
Rkive 1.90b1 -mm2 -mt 12249497 104.27% 162:50 1024.10% 144:26 5855.40%
Ufa32 0.03b4 -m4 -mq2 12316062 104.84% 18:46 118.02% 17:44 718.91%
-m4 -mx 12339341 105.04% 88:36 557.23% 16:07 653.37%
-m5-mu16 12918549 109.97% 51:59 326.93% 55:17 2241.21%
Esp 1.92 /mm2 /ml7 12660411 107.77% 10:10 63.94% 0:39 26.35%
/m2 /mm2/ml7 12697833 108.09% 5:06 32.07% 0:39 26.35%
/m3 /mm2/ml7 13625893 115.99% 1:45 11.00% 0:41 27.70%
Rar 2.02 -mm -m5 -s- 13298941 113.21% 4:21 27.35% 2:40 108.10%
-mm -m3 -s- 13308609 113.29% 4:05 25.68% 2:40 108.10%
-mm -m1 -s- 13338638 113.54% 3:55 24.63% 2:41 108.78%
Pkzip 2.04g -ex 16650031 141.73% 5:19 33.43% 0:36 24.32%
(none) 16741609 142.51% 3:23 21.27% 0:35 23.64%
-es 19818636 168.71% 1:27 9.11% 0:37 25.00%
Eri32 3.0c -3d 11845423 100.83% 17:16 108.59% 4:03 164.18%
Eri32 3.0c -m3-3d 11852781 100.90% 8:24 52.83% 3:54 158.10%
Eri32 3.0c -m2-3d 11985129 102.02% 5:39 35.53% 3:25 138.51%
Display -i --same -bpng
filter=5,level=9 15131718 128.81% 16:18 102.51% 1:31 61.48%
filter=1,level=9 15171412 129.15% 15:17 96.12% 1:20 54.05%
filter=1,level=5 15493033 131.88% 5:20 33.54% 1:29 60.13%
filter=1,level=1 15876308 135.15% 3:08 19.70% 1:27 58.78%
CompuShow 2000! (auto) 15181076 129.23% 9:58 62.68 failed (k15.png: runtime
CompuShow 2000! (1) 15404089 131.13% 7:59 50.20 error 004 at 084E:07CB)
about 4:10 168.91%
Alchemy ---n (4) 15594092 132.74% 21:18 133.96% 4:41 189.86%
*** This set compressed to 11,612,833 bytes only can be found
at ftp://ftp.iis.nsk.su/upload/
or ftp://poctok.iae.nsk.su/incoming/
or ftp://labchem.comcen-1.nsk.su/incoming/
[[3]] Details
Files for first four tests were taken from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/
than converted from Sun Raster format to Windows Bitmap,
(this conversion changes image headers only, 32 bytes
are replaced by 54 bytes, but image data is not modified)
and some of them were slightly renamed.
Files for last three tests are from ftp://download1.intel.com/pressroom/images/
and converted from TIFF format to Windows Bitmap.
The "+" symbol shows absolutely best result;
"." indicates relatively best result;
"`" means you see here not "RAR -m5-mm" but better "RAR -m5-mmF" result.
(1) All files from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/still/KodakImages/color/
ERI32 ERI32 ERI32 ERI32 UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE ESP RAR
Name -3 -3b -3c -3d -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mm2-mt /mm2/ml7 -m5-mm
KODAK01 550879 544741 543582+ 547234 576117 590831 557873 587326 `595993
KODAK02 503765 502806 500898. 504048 531914 439859+ 454943 542769 560515
KODAK03 445777 440098 437308. 441561 442190 412199 395783+ 457348 479882
KODAK04 512226 506057+ 510013 507255 527303 557372 510050 543304 561777
KODAK05 590365 584838 583728+ 586186 630594 739749 702244 647138 `659195
KODAK06 534754 510648. 517207 518307 507543 546118 490952+ 520057 521663
KODAK07 468022 461437 458028. 461202 483942 468697 444912+ 501429 524518
KODAK08 586856 581020+ 581038 581052 660991 741525 734632 674458 `797076
KODAK09 494074 491051 485831. 488530 508908 475900 465972+ 523248 540592
KODAK10 500501 494437 491575+ 493959 515487 515263 503790 528643 542105
KODAK11 501488 492294+ 498878 496532 509321 548388 499252 520874 534221
KODAK12 476090 466289 459217. 468868 456707 442651 404518+ 472662 488519
KODAK13 636361 627484 624065+ 629958 644565 745239 710651 655366 `657081
KODAK14 561094 555787+ 557361 558699 558481 645107 593510 575924 `583175
KODAK15 496997 498562 474467+ 494562 535542 511943 516268 551919 583374
KODAK16 484719 474476. 475493 479351 448516 422314 386221+ 460167 `462303
KODAK17 499133 493768 492395 492227. 508128 497801 476945+ 521333 530944
KODAK18 590633 587203 585962+ 586946 626152 741175 702188 642609 655754
KODAK19 530987 528520 523631+ 525811 556875 577487 560056 571154 581968
KODAK20 498296 389096. 418973 397513 457815 411816 388462+ 468700 `457656
KODAK21 543562 530847. 532335 533513 526458 556123 514424+ 537018 541205
KODAK22 557934 545361+ 549930 546185 607013 709573 658481 620143 628545
KODAK23 480082 474721 472701+ 473782 517230 619870 565407 533774 545563
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
23 1204459_1178154_1177461_1181328_1233779_1291700_1223753_1265736`13056078
230.43% 102.29% 100.05% 100% 100.32% 104.78% 109.70% 103.93% 107.49% 110.88%
Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow 2000! Alchemy Pkzip
Name (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto best of ---n -ex
1 2 3 4 5 (5) 1,2,3,4 (4)
KODAK01 760243 785332 781283 742508+ 744472 762998 762609 752856 828292
KODAK02 637806 631332 640438 641660 628700. 623734+ 650267 646034
KODAK03 506472+ 552842 545028 552492 545043 545256 514003 565998 552355
KODAK04 640129+ 649547 650814 651324 650047 644746 643764 660662 723526
KODAK05 805327 814347 793711 799815 790801+ 797555 813402 875717
KODAK06 631185+ 730872 690743 673603 647047 659763 647885 684451 737475
KODAK07 560317+ 605119 601086 576780 577133 574779 564797 589557 636420
KODAK08 859827 818692 859875 772006 771221+ 776922 784527 891165
KODAK09 622086 602937+ 631443 615120 604798 604043 609502 624622 668032
KODAK10 627165 612863+ 630447 624075 622986 620906 619721 633997 695882
KODAK11 630792 678618 665875 650179 629707+ 632324 662138 676451
KODAK12 533855+ 587442 579178 575505 572357 571824 541380 586269 582646
KODAK13 859453+ 893400 864888 875111 860933 877739 887651 889163 885606
KODAK14 702857+ 755415 726264 728531 723441 727468 716674 739422 790025
KODAK15 627321 602857 624318 623391 620407. 617728+ 635627 682665
KODAK16 541290+ 635649 605486 599170 566271 572778 551551 608718 565643
KODAK17 629130 619624+ 631592 638803 631751 632073 628637 649573 701272
KODAK18 794914 802504 781041. 796841 781199 778873+ 779938 807820 886756
KODAK19 712888 717644 726334 697335 696470+ 697516 706185 792877
KODAK20 499339+ 521502 508982 514091 505651 506171 506653 526609 563411
KODAK21 652334+ 709780 691157 689787 675154 681773 667076 698358 682803
KODAK22 742482 709990. 715696 718174 711990 704754+ 712704 726295 831781
KODAK23 594200 563001. 583480 588854 574139 569353 562659+ 597577 753681
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
23 1517141_1560130_1552915_1534515_1513171_15181076 1559409_16650515
230.43% 128.84% 132.49% 131.88% 130.32% 128.51% 128.93% 132.43% 141.41%
(2) All files from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/sequence/mobile/color/
+some files from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/sequence/football/color/
+some files from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/sequence/susie/color/
ERI32 ERI32 ERI32 ERI32 UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE ESP RAR
Name -3 -3b -3c -3d -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mm2-mt /mm2/ml7 -m5-mm
MOBILE01 659520 659293 660178 658276+ 677429 853011 802220 699840 707837
MOBILE02 658817 658617 659613 657473+ 677685 852798 802774 700015 707730
FOOTBAL0 428122 448600 424865+ 427252 451454 620258 497446 471341 528677
FOOTBAL1 429501 449679 425211+ 427248 454833 634967 507156 475628 `531900
FOOTBAL2 430739 449575 425633+ 428470 460617 651515 518946 481351 536298
FOOTBAL3 435396 452721 429243+ 432351 467976 663764 526861 489102 544646
FOOTBA50 452769 469110 446436+ 446901 487125 712964 569579 511074 577037
FOOTBA70 445314 465089 441428+ 442537 491860 715774 571810 516218 580861
FOOTBA96 453377 471111 449358+ 452744 495665 716741 579021 521042 589896
SUSIE000 350517 374356 343652 342972+ 387336 530607 382018 405150 439348
SUSIE001 349041 373556 344235 343537+ 384451 526452 378407 402008 435958
SUSIE002 351441 375503 345371 344209+ 382391 523257 375646 399418 432825
SUSIE003 348587 373644 343729 342904+ 383657 525992 377575 400859 434096
SUSIE050 339703 362522 333775 333494. 341503 442589 310731+ 356121 398955
SUSIE100 345417 370102 340708 339868+ 379328 505339 367320 396354 431843
SUSIE149 347824 372064 342523 342491+ 379287 501284 364805 396105 433630
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
16files 6826085 7125542 6755958 6762727 7302597 9977312 7932315 7621626 8312590
253.03% 101.03% 105.47% 100% 100.10% 108.09% 147.68% 117.41% 112.81% 123.04%
Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow 2000! Alchemy Pkzip
Name (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto sub ---n -ex
1 2 3 4 5 (5) (1) (4)
MOBILE01 847418 857156 816610 824787 812052. 792052+ 832485 832912 996813
MOBILE02 847429 856356 816209 824269 812081. 792007+ 832229 832481 996138
FOOTBAL0 552015+ 773986 709796 635611 589882 584153 558670 643356 771899
FOOTBAL1 557619+ 767461 703760 642049 600418 594893 564588 650086 785519
FOOTBAL2 563825+ 773690 711597 642054 624059 611959 571104 650229 799375
FOOTBAL3 570556+ 774274 713995 648738 620492 612278 578827 656871 808949
FOOTBA50 593331+ 791003 732346 671132 639254 636214 604641 681384 857312
FOOTBA70 599653+ 756117 707836 671512 659895 649233 612053 681684 856338
FOOTBA96 605772+ 772304 720652 680299 662265 655700 619451 690920 859166
SUSIE000 493651+ 543563 549914 547873 546490 536797 502407 554238 693540
SUSIE001 490402+ 547459 548882 550114 547246 538092 499075 556638 690959
SUSIE002 486889+ 552220 548266 552319 546494 537948 495165 558836 688775
SUSIE003 488755+ 546754 547171 549566 545898 536843 497079 555949 690983
SUSIE050 416466+ 618682 566008 500796 461186 459994 421386 508653 618084
SUSIE100 483780+ 536510 541776 541587 538536 529164 492199 547709 669767
SUSIE149 483376+ 542581 543858 547083 541715 532483 491696 553293 664913
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
16files 908093_1101011_1047867_10029789 9747963 9599810 917305_1015523_12448530
253.03% 134.41% 162.96% 155.10% 148.45% 144.28% 142.09% 135.77% 150.31% 184.26%
(3) Two files from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/sequence/missa/color/
+all files from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/still/canon/bgr/
ERI32 ERI32 ERI32 ERI32 UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE ESP RAR
Name -3 -3b -3c -3d -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mm2-mt /mm2/ml7 -m5-mm
MISSA000 123351 121532 120327+ 121701 140761 176473 173687 144887 152841
MISSA001 123173 121508 120098+ 121651 141027 176620 174029 145273 153321
ANNOUNCE 326122 316962. 321933 319052 310997 457724 383167 322899 +306833
BEACHGIR 378770 374458 369654+ 373926 381422 452453 417154 389428 378203
BLUEGIRL 374084 369179 364313+ 366533 384643 448433 415452 392986 388317
CABLECAR 402919 396780+ 399638 402112 403578 484989 453974 414165 402898
CORNFILD 436700 428732. 433628 435428 423587 518744 477264 432847`+404302
FLOWER 397124 382787. 386212 383556 397341 507171 465493 404043 +380311
FRUITS 430296 398796 403733 398704. 439423 560318 531074 446386 +396787
GIRL 411984 399931 398334+ 401208 414838 480864 445485 422505 409125
GIRL_LDI 310073 303341. 305499 304792 284843 448513 367274 294611 +280159
HUSTLER 311733 298500. 305994 301766 302645 450585 382116 314310 +297170
KIDS 410302 400945+ 407391 402933 416078 554063 518674 423660 412937
MASUDA1 352648 347628 344249. 348916 337976 428141 377939 343353 +332324
MASUDA2 345648. 352251 346080 352855 341848+ 402726 377063 347952 350569
MODEL 384432 373696 372529. 373372 377353 449718 406823 382280 +370158
PENS 423365 410563. 412514 411315 416997 522746 490717 423328 +405836
SOCCER 438381 423964+ 430835 426158 447108 551577 506852 455397 430973
TANAKA 394211 392956 388900. 393195 384974 457098 424172 389032 +373095
YACHT 400376 392935+ 394374 393838 414442 543194 495841 422294 414636
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
20files 7175692 7007444 7026235 7033011 7161881 9072150 8284250 7311636`7042541
198.27% 102.40% 100% 100.26% 100.36% 102.20% 129.46% 118.22% 104.34% 100.50%
Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow 2000! Alchemy Pkzip
Name (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto best of ---n -ex
1 2 3 4 5 (5) 1,2,3,4 (4)
MISSA000 164670 155933 168064 158340 153834. 151134+ 160093 204738
MISSA001 164898 156279 168148 158357 154599. 151789+ 160165 204849
ANNOUNCE 394567. 473888 415512 408902 403245 395135 393097+ 411862 577479
BEACHGIR 423334 412660 391039. 407785 393588 384170 383050+ 410951 570444
BLUEGIRL 433607 410999 398965. 407156 403892 392684 390462+ 410951 579880
CABLECAR 456895 473116 444428 440808 440729. 427424+ 448497 563795
CORNFILD 490102 511382 474188 475316 469217. 459528+ 480543 588760
FLOWER 448168 454710 425850. 433366 428146 415239+ 416458 436372 630722
FRUITS 474575 480014 451997. 455717 454068 438730+ 440319 460456 640889
GIRL 464427 452646 435194. 442893 435589 421726+ 423649 446502 594308
GIRL_LDI 360142. 455789 390335 387854 381594 374292 360032+ 390401 602537
HUSTLER 380955. 434289 387143 388499 384091 377135+ 380477 391096 567875
KIDS 481279 500974 466533 459339 458988. 444011+ 464240 638084
MASUDA1 387201 404260 372613. 380518 375563 365855 365651+ 384643 553789
MASUDA2 390500 395078 369158. 379715 373482 364025 361806+ 384600 521313
MODEL 431888 422529 401017. 416146 404357 394723 393028+ 418826 570636
PENS 481108 497853 447747 466580 447253. 432936+ 471139 647471
SOCCER 517837 542931 501348 490592 490158. 472749+ 496012 640108
TANAKA 429430 433749 408289. 419682 410397 396897 396592+ 422516 584793
YACHT 474291 495830 470450 443661 443344. 429185+ 446822 627102
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
20files 8249874 8564909 7988018 8021226 7906134 7689367 809668711109572
198.27% 117.73% 122.22% 113.99% 114.46% 112.82% 109.73% 115.54% 158.53%
(4) All files from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/still/jpeg/bgr/
+all files from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/still/usc/bgr/
ERI32 ERI32 ERI32 ERI32 UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE ESP RAR
Name -3 -3b -3c -3d -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mm2-mt /mm2/ml7 -m5-mm
BARB 541516 561049 533914+ 541280 623892 904229 750965 655412 `704650
BOATS 480392 501606 472669+ 480872 537504 727199 568972 559659 593271
FRUITS 239764 233212. 237159 235625 211120+ 211948 224906 222289 230438
GIRL 477837 507525 476732+ 484457 555392 803591 660728 577270 626739
GOLD 536361+ 565883 537566 546808 579435 841982 682310 603360 646050
ZELDA 476198 505747 473309+ 482668 527444 842249 638299 548426 `588827
AIRPLANE 413804 409698+ 416955 410278 421741 461749 455312 429894 `422648
BABOON 634762 633007. 643924 633162 621063 704560 703806 628696`+615548
COUPLE 110805 108387 107916+ 108218 112853 119332 120420 114468 114931
GIRL2 126291 124447 123001. 124541 123140 134054 138518 125013 +122880
GIRL2A 95656 91489. 96363 91694 88253+ 96920 89372 91277 ` 89735
GIRL3 105225 102138 104193 101622+ 113914 140774 140621 115859 116585
HOUSE 112527 112073. 112718 112565 112865 128423 125744 114892 +111944
JELLY_B1 80696 76622 78301 74338+ 82433 94602 88217 87303 ` 77583
JELLY_B2 87891 83526 86422 81945+ 91184 108905 102675 96731 ` 87453
LENA 506745 478835 502060 477894+ 501267 590053 592344 506640 497013
PEPPERS 547306. 561571 556954 561540 525490+ 632367 645119 539321 525872
SAILBOAT 581513 580502. 594038 581410 562683 615213 622464 579973`+556615
SPLASH 420833 389771 422581 389256+ 428832 473215 510888 436801 407307
TIFFANY 500282 435061 497836 434250+ 501139 473547 532268 509769 464709
TREE 130743 130357. 131552 130591 128218+ 144224 144386 130967 `130847
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
21files 7207147 7192506 7206163 7085014 7449862 9249136 8538334 7674020`7813132
198.81% 101.72% 101.51% 101.70% 100% 105.14% 130.54% 120.51% 108.31% 110.27%
Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow 2000! Alchemy Pkzip
Name (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto best of ---n -ex
1 2 3 4 5 (5) 1,2,3,4 (4)
BARB 801657+ 844690 869236 839921 836267 825410 839742 850293 1043504
BOATS 663594+ 735246 751381 721857 717395 703767 680427 729143 878505
FRUITS 215187 221901 219826 224439 214763. 210006+ 214248 230611 228571
GIRL 674463+ 734167 747197 729864 728183 708304 686133 736497 941825
GOLD 703759+ 834153 810019 785172 792118 767605 717126 794911 1020962
ZELDA 642772+ 711385 723397 719402 714993 694772 651747 725492 1002196
AIRPLANE 481880 476710 453687 461920 452661. 440948+ 465802 573566
BABOON 649148 671834 638474 645418 635853. 628498+ 657721 750571
COUPLE 124453 121225 118504 116204 116122. 112133+ 117535 138303
GIRL1 132944 133375 128088 129940 127782. 122779+ 131095 152986
GIRL2 103189 106972 101484 103086 101076. 98850+ 103109 118016
GIRL3 127754 116480 118029 114403 113959. 110394+ 114824 164979
HOUSE 125128 129865 122707 121116 120143. 115102+ 121723 152084
JELLY_B1 88143 81727 79848. 80533 79881 77398+ 77690 80698 116168
JELLY_B2 97660 93341 89855 89518 89160. 87269+ 90228 129448
LENA 546336 519624 515416 520455 511607. 490338+ 526650 718337
PEPPERS 556561 550873 539867 548381 538306. 515706+ 556188 725095
SAILBOAT 589080 591736 569432 580331 568217. 552320+ 589642 710997
SPLASH 455799 444223 429709 432410 429163. 417423+ 436280 622259
TIFFANY 500987 484057 477876 482077 474714. 459008+ 487271 595951
TREE 141217 147602 138749 140050 137737. 134417+ 141213 166228
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
21files 8421711 8751186 8642781 8586497 8500100 8272447 868692610950551
198.81% 118.86% 123.51% 121.98% 121.19% 119.97% 116.75% 122.60% 154.55%
(5) Five (natural) images from http://links.uwaterloo.ca/colorset.base.html
+the longest .BMP from Corel Draw! 6.0 package
+test image from Archive Comparison Test by Jeff Gilchrist
ERI32 ERI32 ERI32 ERI32 UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE ESP RAR
Name -3 -3b -3c -3d -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mm2-mt /mm2/ml7 -m5-mm
LENA 505910 478214 501800 477212+ 500660 589992 591421 505918 496464
MONARCH 482299 476463 477813 475367+ 565169 675917 695248 593009 601034
PEPPERS 358761 355877 355010+ 356749 382585 575493 494421 404768 407111
SAIL 564863 564197+ 571537 566669 627831 759105 748130 642393 648308
TULIPS 540627 524543 546134 524417+ 653009 849260 866313 683870 663406
MONCALIB 200335+ 204222 205500 204377 208411 254834 246220 212537 `219254
ACTEST4 115278+ 120604 118281 117477 135819 207559 175675 147150 `230448
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
7 files 2768073 2724120 2776075 2722268 3073484 3912160 3817428 3189645`3266206
222.40% 101.68% 100.06% 101.97% 100% 112.90% 143.70% 140.22% 117.16% 119.98%
Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow 2000! Alchemy Pkzip
Name (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto best of ---n -ex
1 2 3 4 5 (5) 1,2,3,4 (4)
LENA 546042 519398 514920 520428 511347. 490084+ 526564 718477
MONARCH 666020 660412 633685. 644417 636546 628936 628149+ 654171 833559
PEPPERS 459518 485613 453808 451894 451397. 440335+ 455723 663990
SAIL 816430 845283 791128+ 800850 794585 794017 797314 810839 918368
TULIPS 768660 733790 713744 709048 707486. 692286+ 717979 981793
MONCALIB 243777 239406 235846 235055 233358. 228875+ 238380 281578
ACTEST4 213179 189612+ 223843 203962 202857 201116 192012 208718 270079
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
7 files 3713626 3673514 3566974 3565654 3537576 3475649 3612374 4667844
222.40% 136.41% 134.94% 131.02% 130.98% 129.94% 127.67% 132.69% 171.46%
(6) All files from ftp://download1.intel.com/pressroom/images/bios/
ERI32 ERI32 ERI32 ERI32 UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE ESP RAR
Name -3 -3b -3c -3d -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mm2-mt /mm2/ml7 -m5-mm
AYMAR 739497 710978+ 743415 712470 843788 917468 863843 871372 `830044
BARRETT 704060 676178+ 700769 676242 693936 797670 755603 704071 `704427
CARTER 703162 680213 703153 678973+ 696815 786238 755876 706056 `717868
CRAWFORD 780300 751772 780205 750959+ 764745 872882 841201 774664 `807998
DUNLAP 677067 664235 681695 663139+ 691127 852163 787675 699667 `775084
DYESS 629177 612334+ 631702 612840 659972 824984 755225 669988 `739518
GILL 784980 752003+ 786637 753085 808457 846151 825295 833389 `808840
GROVE 703052 675366+ 711109 679093 776639 812217 789356 803683 `765060
HOWE 943100 895460 919290 892279+ 976055 1125827 1038612 998461 964134
KINNIE 709234 686615+ 706093 687535 750884 810528 767146 774109 740853
MALONEY 998199 989248+ 997729 989508 1005900 1091073 1024746 1030891 989523
GELSNGER 783977 760294+ 780314 761614 836871 921912 874328 862580 824990
MOORE 687255 666881+ 686416 667509 684843 796690 765746 694462 `757855
MINER 942075 915210+ 941102 916134 983622 1049969 993925 1012058 `960032
MILLER 805314 768912 803095 767990+ 779943 859318 846185 791616 `776794
NACHTSHM 667830 645930+ 666358 646495 732768 790449 739038 758936 `729990
OTELLINI 749470 726287+ 748292 727028 780123 827159 784771 805261 `771380
PARKER 670085 647199+ 668404 647330 719935 756101 719241 744639 `714996
BARRET1 1708261 1536653+1677859 1546664 1705870 1632053 1696643 1759656 1637685
GROVEBW 863331 861378 864971 859548+ 898304 953847 882626 916485 909427
POLLACK 1306074 1303507.1307594 1303590 1290383 1253986 1231405+1342958`1290921
RSMITH 1219500 1140761 1210382 1137926+1288587 1454344 1419075 1322291 1258946
VADASZ 641904 611924+ 639368 612644 701988 784864 722927 723747 689578
WHITTIER 681568 661552 681947 661439+ 683736 808940 768392 691862 `747467
YU 669333 645386 668597 645327+ 666971 770010 732349 678042 679793
YU1 1234085 1191015+1205899 1195726 1258300 1551932 1457673 1284073 1220931
GEYER 874166 822721 842301 821238+ 936841 916445 848594 974857 892558
WHETSTON 813049 778850+ 804675 786055 821647 909497 860642 837282 `866626
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
28 2368910_2277886_2355937_2280038_2443905_2677471_2554813_2506715`24573318
197.56% 103.99% 100% 103.42% 100.09% 107.28% 117.54% 112.15% 110.04% 107.87%
Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow 2000! Alchemy Pkzip
Name (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto average ---n -ex
1 2 3 4 5 (5) (3) (4)
AYMAR 941708 910662 874482. 897551 876687 862365+ 864673 906778 1131625
BARRETT 835238 827470 785923. 824341 791112 775873 772806+ 831175 1023391
CARTER 835103 833462 790759. 822979 796199 779672 777209+ 831334 1007877
CRAWFORD 905956 901573 857255 894298 856960. 834412+ 835048 904219 1106989
DUNLAP 892040 876160 828070. 869523 829950 826074 825240+ 879211 1094058
DYESS 833729 795905 743277. 791608 748777 739644 736902+ 797707 1059417
GILL 895870 892978 851498 887907 850928. 827469+ 828160 898328 1063510
GROVE 882923 889729 837859. 861982 840794 837435 836377+ 873947 989071
HOWE 1061601 1008403 978468.1001710 980424 955530+ 956446 1012685 1420534
KINNIE 834422 828511 785503 825096 785487. 768316+ 769176 832704 1031308
MALONEY 1085985 1045311 1004966.1043341 1009537 986231 984367+1052480 1398411
GELSNGER 933555 938273 884956. 925710 885970 866970+ 867516 933878 1160095
MOORE 849381 836674 802870. 828937 805789 791682+ 793166 837583 1025675
MINER 1082515 1053897 1017145.1046176 1018896 998604+ 998687 1057885 1306582
MILLER 910332 914939 875029 905030 874383. 850178+ 851210 916571 1055811
NACHTSHM 826420 820478 770875. 812331 774499 762090 760133+ 819383 1021890
OTELLINI 864409 866387 820012 862322 819948. 799404+ 800052 871306 1056089
PARKER 805480 800113 753466. 796727 756029 742337 741373+ 803674 976816
BARRET1 1777008 1741249 1691593 1700919 1685321.1646662+1660511 1723965 2068946
GROVEBW 1087937 1020915 969311.1032748 976331 967419 963190+1044661 1379440
POLLACK 1448912 1429084 1380216.1439085 1381555 1342158+1342503 1456507 1647711
RSMITH 1407034 1345816 1285825.1322227 1286631 1260853+1263326 1335134 1888042
VADASZ 785981 777537 730097. 763929 736418 723542 720465+ 769941 1022847
WHITTIER 855754 848806 801022. 839389 804287 793957 792304+ 848181 1045978
YU 799283 794058 749272. 786384 751261 736431 736055+ 794068 990965
YU1 1345533 1356198 1276696.1301186 1276985 1234239+1239573 1314355 1873248
GEYER 1013164 1006960 933287. 976173 951887 945511 930126+ 997662 1302419
WHETSTON 999370 979410 925631+ 966020 933094 935454 929244. 982934 1201185
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
28 2779664_2734095_2600536_2702562_2608613_2559051_2557583_2732825_34349930
197.56% 122.02% 120.02% 114.16% 118.64% 114.51% 112.34% 112.27% 119.97% 150.79%
(7) All images from ftp://download1.intel.com/pressroom/images/imaging/
+one image from ftp://download1.intel.com/pressroom/images/internet/
+all natural images from ftp://download1.intel.com/pressroom/images/misc/
ERI32 ERI32 ERI32 ERI32 UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE ESP RAR
Name -3 -3b -3c -3d -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mm2-mt /mm2/ml7 -m5-mm
PI1137A 1284857 1240856 1257609 1240161+1328690 1485788 1381185 1362674 1309037
PI1137B 1814081 1795799+1838199 1799134 1933679 2449544 2435833 1983967 1896916
PI1137C 870046 855226+ 891058 855475 1025495 1153476 1149936 1070657 1364657
ISVRBOX 619653 596064+ 620519 598138 631060 672156 645663 655196 755113
ARCADE 2297261 2279471 2285133 2279134.2290550 2521311 2497547 2330539+2259374
ARCADE1 1451593 1423505 1450113 1423028+1452243 1567927 1581873 1481399 1429635
ARCADE2 1331541 1291170 1310122 1290918.1297462 1380620 1387030 1325417+1278150
AW117_1 787713 773468+ 776995 776840 915670 1281785 1088180 961393 `963768
AW117_5 1518675 1503413 1480919+1496390 1898613 2391141 2169383 1961660 2002110
CARPC 1466468 1457735+1459832 1461674 1537768 1943803 1745068 1576543 1582771
PERIPH 1173615 1163310.1220366 1168836 1248734 906296+ 981393 1306265 1190106
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
11 1461550_1438001_1459086_1438972_1555996_1775384_1706309_1601571_16042286
206.69% 101.63% 100% 101.46% 100.06% 108.20% 123.46% 118.65% 111.37% 111.55%
Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow 2000! Alchemy Pkzip
Name (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto best of ---n -ex
1 2 3 4 5 (5) 1,2,3,4 (4)
PI1137A 1475577 1449755 1366876.1419898 1381079 1352533 1344046+1435011 2060723
PI1137B 2131906 2074568 1991484 1964145 1949315.1888431+1901125 1982907 2957440
PI1137C 1097699 1086527 1055857 1024142 1021764.1002451+1005038 1041436 1386971
ISVRBOX 684253 695561 680919 672065 667082. 655626+ 662464 683469 843808
ARCADE 2443474 2411478 2326619 2350706 2318441.2212784+2232127 2377177 3166231
ARCADE1 1494319 1493905 1443209 1455044 1436330.1373897+1382220 1477815 1858966
ARCADE2 1326990 1320888 1284743 1301254 1279139.1229048+1234757 1322717 1623276
AW117_1 1083179 1114990 1064474 1006610 1006610. 984382+ 984573 1021357 1497018
AW117_5 2202964 1954482 2019828 1937304 1936388.1896574+1897269 1970401 2892003
CARPC 1810467 1787099 1699246 1691885 1689358.1664182+1666576 1720651 2542808
PERIPH 1326811+1425598 1388890 1400797 1385471 1363417 1333101.1419511 1256719
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
11 1707763_1681485_1632214_1622385_1607097_1562332_1564329_1645245_22085963
206.69% 118.75% 116.93% 113.50% 112.82% 111.75% 108.64% 108.78% 114.41% 153.58%
(8) All images from ftp://download1.intel.com/pressroom/images/processors/
+all images from ftp://download1.intel.com/pressroom/images/videoconferencing/
ERI32 ERI32 ERI32 ERI32 UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE ESP RAR
Name -3 -3b -3c -3d -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mm2-mt /mm2/ml7 -m5-mm
AL440LX 816504 799082+ 826244 799893 946581 931843 954233 1000637 1159501
DP05077 1449853 1443733 1436953+1450894 1604187 1604268 1642702 1659269`1580088
DP08187 1178256.1222955 1264454 1225454 1284352 1152694+1159602 1352810`1285618
DP2079A 1407149+1411017 1419776 1408748 1694421 2054179 1999247 1726206 1748012
MMX 880513 874679 883618 867394+1042610 1080415 1022159 1086997 1059047
MMX3 1193654.1207220 1198578 1207236 1144262 993582+1026058 1213356`1214453
MMX4 1093126 1075584 1100165 1075370+1110770 1163406 1174139 1145075`1166414
MP02177 1456165 1401987+1428278 1412901 1446730 1524594 1542934 1498104`1441457
MP9089A 881360 860724+ 877309 868790 1054700 1021232 992354 1143258`1190223
MP9089B 1124009 1034078+1052572 1035281 1262093 1465056 1476636 1321228`1295446
PS02037 997443 988901.1014307 998886 935278+ 937609 968523 1015642 1056011
PS06027 1153024 1135906+1151896 1138573 1185044 1328602 1290464 1210571`1254572
PS09157 1606819+1613931 1661396 1610868 1719412 1992005 2007832 1771637 1725427
PS9159B 1486352+1527544 1518542 1532204 1542318 1781718 1829242 1587022 1604721
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
14 1672422_1659734_1683408_1663249_1797275_1903120_1908612_1873181_18992679
232.01% 100.76% 100% 101.42% 100.21% 108.28% 114.66% 114.99% 112.86% 114.43%
Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow 2000! Alchemy Pkzip
Name (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto best of ---n -ex
1 2 3 4 5 (5) 1,2,3,4 (4)
AL440LX 1051048 1043560 1031703 995584 990095. 978799+ 984969 1009926 1179467
DP05077 1728703 1736014 1648525.1685665 1660985 1631405 1625976+1714750 2039666
DP08187 1355045 1339883 1281322+1332376 1294907 1293130 1281569.1361380 1565553
DP2079A 1928034 1942367 1863861 1734908 1734899.1680372+1680613 1756995 2329473
MMX 1120112 1033317 1015838 1012864 1011704.1004292+1005404 1043846 1493058
MMX3 1253516 1293643 1208297.1269880 1236608 1231754 1205745+1306469 1359115
MMX4 1323827 1315328 1261956.1285579 1272914 1257878 1255924+1304576 1568001
MP02177 1581706 1632889 1519667.1566777 1552965 1534452 1508088+1598469 2067519
MP9089A 1092889 1080658 1067926 1068545 1063726.1059267+1064220 1110411 1298976
MP9089B 1328885 1293899 1242296 1247912 1235891.1212884+1222527 1283932 1822110
PS02037 1166981 1141545 1126485 1104507 1098993+1099156.1104169 1113911 1353274
PS06027 1397820 1362198 1309230.1321061 1311962 1296075+1301733 1340723 1840092
PS09157 1880363 1929976 1799620.1847993 1814929 1781751 1772015+1874752 2577626
PS9159B 1777963 1761190 1671955 1700405 1665417.1636080+1647615 1725492 2338459
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
14 1998689_1990646_1904868_1917405_1894599_1869729_1866056_1954563_24832389
232.01% 120.42% 119.93% 114.76% 115.52% 114.15% 112.65% 112.43% 117.76% 149.61%
[[4]] How to download archivers
Those times of alpha-beta versions are gone! Download Bmp2Eri 1.1,
a shorter freeware version fully compatible with Eri32 3.0c4
(and compressing True Color images exactly as 3.0c4):
Bmp2Eri 1.1 : http://www.geocities.com/SiliconValley/Bay/1995/bmp2eri1.zip (120K)
Rkive 1.90b1 : http://www.geocities.com/SiliconValley/Peaks/9463/rkv190b1.zip (91K)
Ufa32 0.03b4 : http://www.geocities.com/SiliconValley/Lakes/9584/ufa003b4.zip (61K)
Rar 2.02 : ftp://ftp.simtel.net/pub/simtelnet/msdos/arcers/rar202.exe (267K)
Pkzip 2.04g : ftp://ftp.simtel.net/pub/simtelnet/msdos/arcers/pkz204g.exe (197K)
Esp 1.92 : ftp://ftp.elf.stuba.sk/pub/pc/pack/esp_v192.exe (68K)
[[5]] PLEASE read THIS before replying to this article!
(1) Millions of thanks for your suggestions and attension!
Since the first release of this test we have received many
positive replies by E-mail.
While the only two negative responses were posted to newsgroops!
(If you don't remember, they were:
from Harald Feldmann, author of HAP, to comp.compression
from Horst Hackenbruch, a BBS sysop, to comp.compression.research
You can still find them, at www.dejanews.com for example.)
That's why, if you want to tell us something like this:
> P.s. I filter anything coming from hotmail as unwanted spam.
or like this:
> direct know what is happend... - an total unusefull nonsens not more or less.
> you are unable to correct many reported simpel errors at this ARI "program"
> over a long time. As excample "FCBS".
please don't post such "news" to a newsgroop, send them to us by E-mail.
If you hate hotmail, or don't like hotmail users,
or simply don't like what doesn't bring you (or your groop)
money or pleasure (now or later), most probably without even
noticing that as usual (nO! of course that's nOt about YOU),
please don't give such thoughts a tongue. Try to process them inside.
(2) The second reason why we ask you not to post negative responses
to newsgroop(s) is that we shall not answer ANY replies
by other way than E-mail.
Unfortunately we don't have much time to read and/or reply articles:
some of us don't speak english, many others are free away from any
networking stuff, even now, when we receive so many e-mails every day.
So, whatever you say about our tests in a newsgroop, we shall nOt answer
there, only by E-mail.
(3) Please don't feel angry, ignored or offended if you won't receive
any reply from us to your E-mail. We are really sorry, but we don't
have enough time to carefully read and answer all incoming E-mails.
Currently only two men can reply you (never more than three),
but only one, Alexander, usually does.
Send your suggestions, comments to ratush@srsc-gw.sscc.ru
(the old addresses Raoinc@hotmail.com and ras@okibox.iae.nsk.su
are still valid but are checked not too often)
With best kind regards,
RAO Inc.
P.S.
Once again:
PLEASE! if you are going to answer this article,
find the above mentioned replies and re-read them
to understand what we are writing about,
what "news" we ask you not to post